New Delhi: Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia have emerged as the world’s three largest historical exporters of carbon emissions, according to a new study that challenges the conventional method of assigning responsibility for global warming. The findings, released as the COP31 climate summit enters its decisive negotiating phase in Turkey’s Antalya, have intensified scrutiny of countries that profit from selling fossil fuels abroad while reporting substantially lower emissions within their own borders.
The analysis published by Carbon Brief examines the carbon dioxide released from coal, oil and natural gas extracted and exported by countries since 1850, tracing the climate impact of fuels subsequently burned elsewhere. It identifies Russia as the largest historical exporter, followed by Saudi Arabia and Australia, raising questions about whether international climate accounting adequately reflects the responsibilities of major energy producers.
Russia accounts for approximately 69 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide associated with historical fossil fuel exports, reflecting its extensive oil, gas and coal production across successive political eras. Saudi Arabia follows with roughly 61 billion tonnes, principally linked to its petroleum industry, while Australia’s coal and liquefied natural gas exports account for approximately 28 billion tonnes.
The three countries together have exported fossil fuels responsible for more than 155 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions over the past 175 years, according to the estimates. Venezuela, Iran, Indonesia, Kuwait, Iraq, the United Arab Emirates and Norway also feature prominently among historical exporters, demonstrating how a relatively small group of resource-rich nations has supplied much of the world’s carbon-intensive energy demand.
Why findings change the emissions debate?
The study’s significance lies in how it measures responsibility rather than in identifying previously unknown emissions. Under the conventional system used in United Nations climate reporting, emissions are generally attributed to the country where fossil fuels are burned, regardless of where the coal, oil or gas originated.
Carbon Brief instead uses an extraction-based approach, assigning emissions to the countries that supplied the fuels ultimately responsible for releasing carbon dioxide. The calculations draw on historical data compiled by Robbie Andrew, a senior researcher at Norway’s Cicero climate research institute, and allocate emissions associated with former multinational states according to present-day national boundaries.
This produces substantial changes in the historical rankings, particularly for countries whose economies depend on fossil fuel exports. Saudi Arabia’s cumulative emissions responsibility increases more than fourfold under the alternative calculation, placing it fifth globally, while Australia’s historical contribution more than doubles and moves it into the top 10.
The United States and China nevertheless remain the two largest contributors to historical warming under extraction-based accounting because both have extracted and consumed enormous quantities of fossil fuels. Conversely, energy-importing countries such as Japan, Germany, India and Turkey move down the rankings when emissions linked to imported fuels are reassigned to their producers.
The distinction has important implications for climate diplomacy, although extraction-based figures do not replace the internationally agreed territorial emissions inventories. Researchers caution that responsibility cannot be transferred entirely to producers because importing governments, businesses and consumers also determine how energy is purchased, used and regulated.
Australia faces scrutiny over expanding fossil-fuel exports
The findings are particularly uncomfortable for Australia, which is co-presiding over COP31 alongside Turkey and leading negotiations on the summit’s outcome. A separate Climate Analytics report released Tuesday estimates that emissions from Australian fossil fuel exports reached approximately 1.2 billion tonnes in 2025, with government projections indicating only a gradual decline over the following 15 years.
According to the report, the government led by the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, has approved at least 37 new or expanded coal, oil and gas projects since taking office in 2022. Some coalmining permissions extend as far as 2088, almost four decades beyond Australia’s declared target of achieving net-zero emissions by 2050.
The Australian government maintains that its energy exports help importing countries meet their requirements during the transition towards cleaner energy. Saudi Arabia has similarly rejected the suggestion that exporters should shoulder responsibility for all emissions generated overseas, arguing that importing countries control how purchased fuels are used and how their environmental consequences are managed.
COP31 negotiations expose widening divisions
The controversy coincides with difficult negotiations over the future of fossil fuels at COP31, where a draft agreement released on Monday proposes accelerating the transition away from coal, oil and gas. The document also recommends increasing electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035, alongside measures covering climate finance, carbon capture and emissions reductions.
However, resistance from major fossil fuel-producing countries threatens to dilute the final agreement, with negotiations scheduled to conclude on November 20. The draft additionally addresses technologies for removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, an increasingly contentious proposal on Monday, although such measures are intended to supplement rather than replace direct emissions cuts.
For India, the new research adds another dimension to longstanding debates over historical responsibility, energy security and equitable climate financing. As a major fossil fuel importer with substantial development needs, India faces the challenge of reducing emissions without compromising affordable energy access, even as it accelerates renewable-energy deployment.
That transition is already producing economic benefits, with a recent International Energy Agency assessment indicating that India’s renewable-energy expansion helped avoid more than $100 billion in coal and natural gas import expenditure between 2011 and 2025, as RNA Media reported on November 13. The broader question emerging from COP31 is whether future climate agreements can distribute responsibilities fairly between countries that extract fossil fuels, those that purchase them and those that have historically benefited most from their consumption.
