New Delhi: Deborah Bergamini, an ally of the Italian prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, has criticized the Italian socialist leader, Giacomo Filibeck, over his remarks on Indian democracy, saying it was inappropriate for Europeans to lecture India on democratic values. In a post on X on Monday, Bergamini objected to Filibeck’s support for India’s Congress party’s call for the government to step down, arguing that India has its own democratic institutions and judiciary to address electoral disputes.
“I believe everyone in a democracy is free to put forward whatever arguments or accusations they wish, provided they can substantiate them,” she said.
She further objected to foreign political representatives intervening in the domestic debate of a friendly country, pointing to the special strategic partnership between India and Italy.
“Moreover, as Europeans, we find it inappropriate to lecture on democracy a nation that enables 970 million citizens to cast their votes. India possesses its own political institutions and judiciary; any conflicts or disputes should be addressed and resolved in accordance with the established rules of democracy,” she added.
What triggered Bergamini’s response?
Her remarks followed an address by Giacomo Filibeck, secretary general of the Party of European Socialists (PES), at the Bharat Summit 2026, organized by the Indian National Congress in Hyderabad on Saturday.
Speaking on the sidelines of the summit, Filibeck said Indian democracy was facing challenges and called for international support for congress leader Rahul Gandhi.
“Democracy is under attack in India, and we need to defend it, and the best way to defend it is to stand by Rahul Gandhi and the Indian Congress party,” he said.
He also backed Gandhi’s campaign for clean and transparent electoral rolls and raised a Congress party slogan targeting the BJP-led government.
India-Italy ties in focus
Bergamini’s intervention is significant because Forza Italia is part of the governing coalition supporting Meloni. However, her remarks should not be treated as an official statement by the Italian government.
India and Italy upgraded their relationship to a special strategic partnership in May this year, covering cooperation in areas including trade, defence, technology and science.
The exchange has brought India’s domestic political debate into an international setting, with two Italian political figures taking opposing positions. While Filibeck has defended his comments as support for democratic principles, Bergamini has argued that India’s institutions should address its electoral disputes.
The remarks have prompted political reactions in India but have not, so far, established a formal diplomatic dispute between New Delhi and Rome.
